Tips for Great Coaching Conversations for Managers

In the fast-paced, dynamic atmosphere of the modern workplace, coaching conversations have become an essential tool for managers. With a multi-generational workforce that includes a significant proportion of younger employees, the traditional command-and-control style of management is giving way to a more collaborative and empowering approach. In particular, younger generations have shown a preference for coaching-style conversations that offer guidance and development rather than directive instructions. Employees are seeking more control over their career, and the role of a manager is vital in employees feeling satisfied in their role and having a confidence that their employer can offer the right progression opportunities.

However, many managers that I work with are struggling to know how to engage in coaching conversations, often fearing they lack the necessary skills to effectively talk like a coach. This concern is not unfounded, as coaching requires a distinct set of communication and interpersonal skills, with qualifications and accreditations now being offered by a number of providers.

The Importance of Coaching Conversations

With the right mindset and tools, any manager can transform their interactions into meaningful coaching opportunities that drive performance, foster talent, and enhance job satisfaction.

Coaching conversations are not just about improving performance; they are about building relationships, understanding individual motivations, and helping team members navigate their career paths.

For managers, the ability to conduct these conversations can lead to a more engaged and motivated team, increased productivity, and a culture of continuous learning and improvement. A more positive working environment may also lead to retaining team members, which can reduce the recruitment burden on your organisation.

Overcoming Hesitations

It's natural for managers to feel apprehensive about adopting a coaching style, especially if they are accustomed to more traditional management methods. Concerns about the time investment required, or doubts about their ability to facilitate rather than direct, can be barriers. However, the benefits of coaching conversations far outweigh these hesitations, and with practice, any manager can become an effective coach.

10 Top Tips for Effective Coaching Conversations

The below are 10 simple steps that, when followed, can lead to coaching-style conversations across any manager-employee engagement, whether that is around personal development, performance issues, regular check-ins or with regards to particular projects or work tasks.

Active Listening: Truly listen to what your team members are saying without interrupting or formulating your response while they are speaking. This shows respect and allows for a deeper understanding of their perspectives.
Using Silence: Don’t be afraid of pauses. Silence can be a powerful tool that gives individuals time to think and reflect, often leading to more insightful contributions. If you think you have let the silence last long enough, force yourself to leave it a few seconds more. That can often lead to "AH HA" moments.
Asking Open Questions: Use open-ended questions that start with ‘what’, ‘how’, or ‘tell me about…’ to encourage discussion and deeper thinking.
The GROW Model: Utilise the GROW (Goal, Reality, Options, Will) model to structure your coaching conversations, helping team members to set clear goals and work through challenges. Engaging in a coaching relationship yourself can deepen your understanding of the GROW model and help you to utilise it more effectively
Empathy: Show empathy and understanding. Acknowledge feelings and perspectives to build trust and open communication.
Encouraging Self-Reflection: Prompt team members to reflect on their experiences and identify what they’ve learned. This can lead to self-discovery and personal growth.
Non-Directive Approach: Avoid the temptation to provide solutions. Instead, guide team members to find their own answers, which can be more empowering and lead to greater ownership.
Challenge and Feedback: Provide balanced feedback that recognises strengths and areas for development. Ensure it is specific, constructive, and actionable. If you think that there is an opportunity to challenge, offer the feedback rather than give it without permission, and word it to acknowledge that it is your perspective. For example "can I offer some feedback here? This is just my perspective, but what I am hearing is…" A really effective open challenge question is "I wonder if something else is going on here"
Goal Setting: Help team members to set specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) goals to provide direction and motivation.
Follow-Up: Coaching is an ongoing process. Schedule follow-up conversations to check on progress, offer support, and adjust goals as necessary.

Coaching conversations are a vital part of modern management, particularly in a workplace that values personal growth and development, and traditional coaching conversations can be subtly tweaked to give employees more opportunity to shape their ongoing careers.

While some managers may initially feel out of their depth, the transition to a coaching style of conversation is well within reach. By embracing the tips outlined above, managers can create a positive and practical framework for engaging with their teams. This not only enhances the individual and team performance but also contributes to a culture of continuous learning and mutual respect. As managers become more comfortable with coaching conversations, they will find these interactions to be among the most rewarding aspects of their role.

If this article has resonated with you, please reach out to discuss engaging in some coaching yourself, which will give you the opportunity to work on some of these challenges.

Tom Wallin is a career and executive coach focused on ensuring that clients fulfil their potential. He regularly coaches clients across a wide range of topics, typically focused on career progression or overcoming hurdles to achieve goals.

Having coached both formally and informally since 2012, in 2023 he completed a Diploma in Executive Coaching. He has hundreds of hours of coaching experience and is currently working towards ICF accreditation.

If you are interested in exploring coaching in more detail, you can contact Tom via my website here or via LinkedIn.

Careers
Leadership & Management